This oyster stew recipe is sort of my flagship recipe, partly because of this blog’s name, and partly because I’ve been perfecting it over the years and it is really, really good.
It also encompasses the best things about food, for me: simplicity, fresh and local ingredients, historical and cultural importance.
- 1 dozen freshly-shucked oysters (separated from liquor)
- 1 or 2 medium shallots, sliced thin
- 1 or 2 cups milk or cream
- 1/4 cup hot water
- 1 or 2 tbsp butter
- salt and pepper to taste
- In one pan, cook the shallots in milk over a low-medium heat.
- When they get close to boiling, turn down the heat and let them simmer.
- In another pan, cook the oyster liquor and water.
- When the liquid bubbles, add the oysters.
- When the oysters ruffle, add the butter.
- Stir lightly until the butter is melted.
- Mix together the contents of the pans.
- Simmer on low for a while, then serve warm. Be sure to get a good whiff of it before digging in.
I’ve adapted this, over several years, from a recipe from the 1906 Inglenook Cook Book:
Drain the liquor from 2 quarts of oysters. Mix it with a small teacupful of hot water; add a little salt and pepper; set it over the fire in a granite saucepan; let it boil up once, then put in the oysters and let them come to a boil. When they ruffle, add 2 tablespoonfuls of butter; when melted and well stirred in, add a pint of boiling milk or part milk and cream. Take from the fire and serve with oyster crackers. If a plain stew is liked, add boiling water instead of the milk and more butter.
Because the oyster flavor (primarily from the liquor) is the real highlight of this stew, I find that the simpler the recipe, the better. That said, some variety is nice. Traditional variations include cayenne or paprika, celery or celery salt. I’ve also experimented with adding leeks (in place of the shallot), kelp noodles (nice due to their neutral flavor and ability to soak up goodness), and fresh herbs (sparingly; rosemary and thyme are recommended).
I pretty much always get my oysters from the Matunuck Oyster Farm (now also a ridiculously good restaurant), in my home-state of Rhode Island. Theirs are the best oysters I’ve ever had, with the possible exception of those from a farmers’ market in Galway City, Ireland. I’d have to taste them at the same time to declare a victor, and that will never happen, because of course they’d have to be at their freshest possible.
(PS. M.F.K. Fisher’s book Consider The Oyster is a must-read for oyster fans and includes all sorts of recipes, including many for stew.)
STANDARD FTC DISCLOSURE: In order for me to support my blogging activities, I may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this blog. Please note that I only ever endorse products that are in alignment with my ideals and that I believe would be of value to my readers.